From 2001-2005 there was a class of Democrats that emerged from the rise of the Warner-Kaine Democrat Party in Northern Virginia. Some were younger, some had local public service behind them, and all unified around, they took Fairfax and Loudoun by storm and help turn Fairfax County blue. They were Chap Petersen, Steve Shannon, David Bulova, Mark Sickles, Chuck Caputo, Margi Vanderhye, David Poisson, and Dave Marsden.
One thing they all also had in common was a completely disfunctional Republican Party in Fairfax County. During the 2000s, there was no more poorly run organization than the FCRC, often ravaged by internal dissent, bad candidate recruitment, and divisive primaries that turned voters away rather than build up a coaltion, the ability to challenge these new Democrats was never there. And in many ways, that should be the story of why Democrats roared to power in Northern Virginia. Make no mistake, all these candidates were tireless campaigners and had popular governors behind them. But there was no lower point for Republicans locally than in the 2001-2007 years, or as I like to call it, The Jeannemarie Years.
Tom Davis, when I first got active in 2005, was universally seen as both the party's strongerst advocate and its savior. Over and over I heard people discount the problems by saying "oh, but Tom can count votes," or 'oh, we have Tom, we'll be okay. But the Tom Davis of the 1990s, the tireless Republican recruiter that helped get Republicans like Jay O'Brien, Dave Albo, Jeannemarie Devolites, Jane Woods, among others - that Tom Davis was gone. When he married Jeannemarie Davis the two of them became the most important thing in Fairfax County politics, or more importantly, she became the most improtant thing in Fairfax County politics. Redricting in Fairfax centered around creating a Senate seat for Devolites. The storming of Fairfax by Mark Warner was catching a party that went from a unified force to a Party of Two. More and more, desperate Republicans were lurching for ways to stay elected because they no longer had the full attention of the kingpin congressmen. Scared of the oncoming rush lead by Mark Warner and Tim Kaine, and worried they didn't have the wisdom at home supporting them, Republicans were left in the wind in Northern Virginia and suddenly Republican delegate and senators were being picked off left and right. First was Petersen's upset of Jack Rust in 2001, then Shannon taking Devolites seat in 2003. Then in 2005, Republicans in Fairfax completely imploded with divisive primaries where the wrong candidate was nominated in the 67th (Reese-Craddock), the 37th (Mason-Kaplan), and the 41st (Marsden-Dillard-Golden imbriglio) come more to mind. Anti-tax candidates sprung up everywhere and instead of leading to a groundswell of conservative grassroots, these races helped destroy the local party. And then two years later, we lost two senators in Jay O'Brien and Jeannemarie Davis.
It was this backdrop of Republican chaos, selfishness, and fractricide that these Democrats rose in. They continuelly wrapped themselves in the Warner flag, ran on doing whats best for Fairfax, but generally lacked any sort of philosophy, instead trying to create a "centrist" image but doing very little in the General Assembly. For four years they had the Republican turmoil locally and the deterioation of the Republican brand nationally. For four years they got to run giving lip service to local issues like transportation, but really hammered Republcians on the very unpopular George W. Bush. But for all of these delegates (and one senator) are backbenchers and never really did anything because they did not have too. In 2007, the last year of the Jeannemarie Years, the Davises sacrificed the entire local party to get her reelected. The word was out . . . don't run delegates in any distirct in JMDD's senate district. Tom went around locals enforcing his edict and when one man dared to give the voters a choice (Arthur Perves) he was attacked and savaged as much by Republicans as by Democrats. In the end, we looked feckless and withou ideals and everyone lost but the one candidate who ran as a conservative, on principle, and engaged in his community at a local level (Cuccinelli).
And then Steve Shannon ran for Attorney General.
Shannon, I believe, expected his race for AG to go as his races for delegate had gone. The Republicans were engaged in a tough primary that threated to depress the party, he was getting great press as a young Democrat shooting start who had made no mistakes and done nothing wrong because, like every single other Democrat from Fairfax, they had essentially done nothing. And you can't blame Shannon, its all he knew. He saw what the Republicans were doing, and his pace of campaigning wasn't that great and generally he hadn't faced any serious opposition. When Ken Cuccinelli was nominated, many on both sides of the aisle predicted that Shannon easily defeat him because on the surface Shannon had everything and Cuccinelli was just some right-winger with a fringe following.
But Shannon represents all these Fairfax Democrats better than almost anyone else. They look good, sound good, show energy, and are considered almost cool. But its all vanity, its all gilded. What you seen on the surface is not what the reality is. It had now been eight years since Chap Petersen got this ball rolling by beating Jack Rust, and all the things these Democrats had talked about doing had not happened. They told them they would fix transportation, they haven't. They promised they would fix the budget, and one giant tax hike later the state was still calling special sessions to deal with the problem. Fairfax Democrats like Steve Shannon had mastered the game, but not the actions.
And it took 2009, where hungry Republicans across Virginia, but especially in Fairfax, were finally free of the insular, be-all-end-all Tom Davis machine that picked favorites and out-thought itself. Instead, we learned to rely on each other and our entire slate of candidates from Bob McDonnell down to Patty Reed all ran as a team. Volunteers bounced around from campaign to campaign eagerly. Money was available, and the state and local unit committees were fired up and organized. For the first time ever, these Fairfax Democrats would be challenged.
In the vangaurd of this move towards party unity was ironically Ken Cuccinelli. Where Davis was seen as the man to build a party, in reality it was Cuccinelli all along. While Davis was turning his back on the party for his wife, Ken was leading a movement in Western Fairfax with Pat Herrity, Tim Hugo, Mike Frey, and Marc Cadin of ticket integration. They shared lists, they created shared literature, they campaigned with each other, their volunteers worked with each other. I remember going out with lit for Ken's campaign and all the downballot candidates in the precinct I was in were there. What happend? All but Cadin won, and he came close. So despite his reputation as a lone-wolf conservative firebrand, Cuccinelli had spent years organizing and unifying Republicans. A change of administrations in Washington and a gubernatorial candidate determiend to go on the offensive in Fairfax rather than play the margins helped drive Republicans.
Steve Shannon had no idea what hit him. For the first time in his career he was being challenged, attacked for his lack of leadership and accomplishments, and his image no longer worked alone for him. The shell game that is these Fairfax Democrats, a game of style of substance, no longer worked because McDonnell, Bolling, and Cuccinelli showed that Democrats like Steve Shannon had no substance. And the voters in Fairfax realized this too. Down went Caputo, down went Vandehye, down went Poisson (I know its Loudoun, but still close), and down went Shannon.
In Steve Shannon being exposed as all style and no substance, he exposed all these Fairfax Democrats. Caputo and Vendehye got "Shannonized."
And so will Dave Marsden.
Marsden might even be worse than any of these others. A political turncoat, Marsden is more of an oppurtunist than any of these others. He's run exclusively on coattails and has yet to prove he can solidify his distirct. He's also a notoriously lazy campaigner who got started late, never took the hard-working Kerry Bolognese seriously, and almost got smoked. That was a sleeper race, and in retrospect perhaps the state party should have looked closer and supporting Bolognese more strongly. But Marsden's performance is further proof that these Democrats were being exposed as political windowdressing. David Bulova ran unopposed but over 30% of his district found someone else to run against.
What awaits Dave Marsden if he runs for the Senate is the fate of Steve Shannon and nother Fairfax Democrats that went down. No longer can they point to Mark Warner or George W. Bush (one good, one bad), no longer can he run on coattails because they won't be there. If he had trouble with fiesty Bolognese, imagine what will happen when the full brunt of the Republican operation statewide from McDonnell, Cuccinelli's district GOTV mastery, and in the local party that has figured out special elections (Herrity almost, Cook, and Reed) unite with Dave Marsden in their sights. Gone is the GOP infighitng both locally and statewide, gone are the influences of Republican kingpins with personal ambition ahead of the party, and gone is the myth that Republicans can't win in Fairfax. Bob McDonnell won Fairfax, and both Bolling and Cuccinelli carried 47% of the district. Steve Hunt himself has carried the 37th all three times in his races for school board, and Pat Herrity won it as well. Sully and Springfield are always Republican nominally, but moreso now that we've won.
Dave Marsden doesn't have the track record, the political record, or any record of legislative accomplishments that merits a promotion to the Senate. His life on the coattails of others are gone, and above all of this he doesn't even live in the distirct! I'm not saying he won't be formidable in some ways, but Republicans are the ones who have the drive right now. I fully expect that Dave Marsden will get "Shannonized" if he runs for the Senate, exposed as a backbencher elected on a false reputation and really on the coattails of others. Left to run on his own, like Shannon (and Vanderhye, Poisson, Caputo) he will be exposed for the do-nothing delegate he's always been.
Ouch, Mr. Speaker.
Recent Comments